So I've completed 3 weeks of calorie counting and just wanted to check in and review my progress.
Did it work?
For me? Honestly? I don't think so! Did I lose weight? Yes a little, but less than expected given previous months weight loss, and how much I stepped up the exercise and diet.
How does that work?
I seem to eat less, and stress about it less, when I focus on healthy eating, rather than calorie counting.
I have had my moments of being a bit obsessive about dieting in the past (overachiever alert!) and I can feel all those tendencies come sneaking back. I've started thinking obsessively about food and when I do that, what happens? I eat more! I noticed that, when compared to just jotting down what I eat (and not adding up the calories) I seemed to eat more when I obsessively count everything. I found myself weighing everything (massive pain in the bum) and worrying about too many carbs, not enough protein, too much fat etc. I cheated more when I started counting, not less, and I felt much guiltier about it!
But am I fooling myself?
Maybe! Maybe forcing myself to track that bite of ice-cream, that glass of wine or apple juice, and all the other little things you forget are calories also mean that you feel as though you eat more. Not sure. As far as I can tell from my inspirational heroines of fitness, they are more about eating wholesomely and healthily rather than obsessively counting calories. I used to stop eating when I'm full. I don't do that now because I've already logged the calories I'm going to darn well eat them. Oh dear. All I can say is I felt better, lost more weight and obsessed less when I didn't count calories.
Other unexpected side-affects
So it turns out tracking my daily calorie intake made me want to weigh myself more, and that let to me getting angry and confused and stressed more. With constant monitoring and analysis it didn't feel as though the healthy eating and exercise increase were natural and organic, it felt more forced and frantic. I started to prefer cardio sessions (yay more calories in the bank) to weights (hmm no calories in the bank, and then weight gain due to DOMS), when I know that is nonsensical.
So am I eating enough?
Haha! I was a little worried I was undereating. Turns out that is not the case. I was actually on about the right level of calories in my 'healthy eating' habit.
Are there any good sides to the calorie counting experiment?
I suppose so. Counting calories has given me a good feel for the right amount to eat in a day. I now know the difference between a 1400 calorie day and a 2400 calorie day (not as much of a difference as you might think). I'm also aware of the foods that pack a bigger calorie punch than expected (typically process naughty food), and those that do less (greens, eggs, lean protein etc). I know I need to be careful about overeating more than undereating too.
Wrap up
Calorie deficit is the basis for weight loss. I'm not denying it. Most diets work (when they work) because they induce calorie deficits to a larger or greater extent. I would say counting calories is a good place to start for anyone who wants to lose weight. But one size does not fit all.
For me I think focusing on strategies that help me to get a good calorie deficit will be far more important than obsessively tracking. You could argue that I'm kidding myself and the results won't be as good, but I'll feel a lot happier.
Also, if I've discovered anything from the long and painful process of saving up to buy a house it's this; tracking alone does not a nest egg make. You need to use tracking as a tool to understand where you are going wrong, then introduce practical tricks and tools to help you address these trouble areas. If you find that tracking alone is the best way to keep to your budget (money or calories) and you don't mind the effort it takes then keep doing it!
These are my new tips and tricks:
- Fill my plate with fresh, organic veg
- Eat mindfully, keep checking in to see when I am no longer hungry
- Drink lots of water
- Try to eat protein with my main meals
- Cut down on alcohol and excess sweet drinks (e.g. fruit juice)
- It's ok to have a treat every now and then, enjoy it and don't feel guilty!